How to Easily Make Yogurt at Home

Learn my ridiculously easy way for homemade yogurt that is cheap, delicious, and lets you control ingredients and taste.

Homemade yogurt is so easy to make it’s almost ridiculous.  If you’re just starting out adding homemade cultured foods into your diet, this is such an easy one to try!

Actually, making yogurt is so easy that it’s almost not even worth dedicating a whole blog post to it. On the other hand, it is so simple that I just want to share it with everyone!

I love adding fermented foods to my meals. 

Fermented foods are full of live beneficial, gut-friendly bacteria that you’ll want to include every day.

YouTube player

Only 2 Ingredients for homemade yogurt

All you need is already-made yogurt and milk.  It’s so nice to know exactly what goes into your food.

You can either buy a small container of your favorite plain yogurt in the grocery store.  If you do, just make sure it contains live active cultures.

yogurt with live active cultures

Next time, it will be easier since you can use your homemade yogurt to make the next batch.

Your other ingredient is milk.  I have to say that I like full-fat milk best for taste and consistency. Yogurt made with skim milk tends to get a bit more tangy and runny.

How to make homemade yogurt

Pour the milk into a pot. Over low-medium heat, slowly heat it up to about 180˚F. You can use a thermometer to monitor the temperature. Also, make sure to stay close to your milk as it can boil over very quickly.

stainless steel pot on stove with yogurt and thermometer reading 180˚F

If you don’t have a thermometer, you can do what I do. I wait until the first signs of skin forming on the milk. I know it’s not super accurate but it has worked well for me.

hot milk with skin forming

Now you need to let the milk cool down. When nice and warm to the touch, add your yogurt. Fortunately, the ratio is flexible: I use about ¼  of yogurt to about 1 quart of milk.  However, it does not have to be exact.  

pouring warm milk into two quart size mason jars on kitchen counter

If you want yogurt done quicker and a bit more sour, you can increase the amount of yogurt. 

If you’d like a mellower taste and have more time, you might get away with adding just a few tablespoons of yogurt.

However, there are other factors such as the temperature, the live strains in your starter culture, etc that will all affect the final result.  Don’t be surprised if you find your yogurt coming out a bit different every time. 

You can also get a starter such as this one.  In this case, you just follow the instructions on the package.  It’s pretty foolproof.  

Back to my method:  Using a whisk, stir everything well and fill it in clean glass jars.  Mason jars are perfect for yogurt! Any size works but I prefer either the pint or the quart size.

Now, let this mixture sit in a warm spot.  100˚-110˚F is the optimal temperature for culturing yogurt. Some ovens go down to that temperature.

a quart size mason jar with yogurt in oven

Don’t have an oven that goes down to 100˚F?

Previously, we had an oven that I could set to 100˚F. Our new stove’s lowest setting is 150˚F. So now I turn the oven to 150˚F, then turn it off, add the jars, and turn the oven off.

knobs showing setting oven temperature to 100˚F

Another option is to only turn on the oven light. Oftentimes, that will warm up the oven enough for culturing yogurt.

The jars can also be quickly wrapped in towels or blankets to keep them warm.  In the winter, the jars can sit on or near a heater.  In the summer, you could set the yogurt into a sunny window sill.

wrapping yogurt in towels

Of course, there are yogurt makers that take all the guesswork out of it. While I haven’t tried this method myself, some people culture their homemade yogurt in an instant pot.

And remember as, with most fermentation processes, the timing here depends on many factors: the temperature, the yogurt-milk ratio, and your own preference

I like to leave my yogurt in the warm oven for at least 4 hours and then check every so often. 

If it’s somewhat solid and jiggly and has a pleasant tangy smell, I will take it out.  I have also let it sit in the oven for as much as 8 hours.  When the yogurt is done, I will put it in the refrigerator where it will set even further.  Your homemade yogurt will keep for a few weeks – if you can manage to not eat it up before …

homemade yoghurt in glass mason jar

If you’re like me, you might like to enjoy your yogurt plain. But you can add any sweetener such as honey or maple syrup and/or toppings of your choice, such as jam, nuts, seeds! 

You can also use it in recipes instead of sour cream.  The possibilities are endless!

Just make sure you keep a small amount of your homemade yogurt for your next batch!

As an added bonus, I love that I am not using any plastic yogurt cups 🙂

spooning homemade yogurt into small bowl on kitchen counter

I would love to hear your comments and questions!

homemade yoghurt in small bowl next to a quart size mason jar with yogurt
how to make yogurt
Print Recipe
4.50 from 4 votes

Homemade Yoghurt

This is such an easy way to make yoghurt that you’ll never want to buy it in the store again.  When done, you can add your favorite sweetener and/or toppings.
Prep Time5 minutes
Cook Time15 minutes
resting and fermenting time5 hours
Course: Side Dish
Cuisine: American
Servings: 4 cups
Calories: 145kcal
Cost: $3

Ingredients

  • 1 quart whole milk
  • ¼ cup plain yogurt

Instructions

  • Over low-medium heat bring your milk to 180˚F (either use thermometer or until skin starts to form on top).
    2. Let milk cool down until you can comfortably touch it.
    3. Using a whisk, add your yogurt until well combined. 
    4. Pour into clean glass jars.
    5. Keep in a warm spot.  The ideal temperature is 100˚-110˚F.  Check your oven if it goes that low.  Otherwise, heat oven to lowest setting, turn it off, leave the light on, and quickly put the jars into oven.  Yogurt can also be fermented close to a heater and/or wrapped in a towel. 
    6. Let ferment for 4 hours.  Check if it has your desired firmness and sourness otherwise continue to let it sit for up to 8 hours.  
    7. Refrigerate yogurt.  This will make it set more. 
    8. Be sure to save anywhere from 1/4 to 3/4 cup of your homemade yoghurt for your next batch!
    Make your own Yoghurt

Nutrition

Calories: 145kcal
Tried this recipe?Mention @ourgabledhome or tag #ourgabledhome!

Repin for Later:

How to Easily Make Yogurt at Home

30 Comments

  1. 5 stars
    I have been making our own homemade yogurt for over 8 years. I started out using an old (non-digital) stove to ferment the yogurt for 8 hours (This was the recommendation). I first had to get the oven temperature dial set at the proper point so I put a pan of water into the oven and set the temperature dial below the 140 degree point. I allowed for an hour each time I checked and adjusted the temperature until the thermometer registered 105 degrees then marked this point on the stove so that I could always go back to this point after the oven was used for cooking. Our kitchen appliances were replaced before I realized that the digital oven would not go below 170 degrees. At that point I purchased a One Pot which had the yogurt program built in. It also has a stainless steel liner which I use in the oven to reach the 180 degree temperature prior to cooling to 105 degrees (in a sink of cold water) and then adding the culture. The One Pot holds 6 quarts and I max it out because I’m only producing a little more than 3 quarts of Greek yogurt after straining the whey which by the way cannot be used to make Ricotta cheese if you’re getting your milk from a grocery store in the U.S. The ultra pasteurizing process is the problem. You can use the whey in any recipe which calls for milk on a one to one ratio without any detriment to the finished product so don’t throw it away, but don’t put it on your bowl of cereal!

  2. Anja – I tried making this recipe twice, I believe I followed all instructions accordingly. The only slight alteration is I’m using lactose-free milk (as I have problems with lactose). Both times, the yogurt never set. I let it ferment for 8+ hours & then refrigerated overnight. Both times, same result. Help! Before I give up, do you have any suggestions what I could possibly be doing wrong? Is whole milk a must?
    Would love to make this work!
    Many Thanks!
    Kristina

    1. The yogurt cultures need the lactose (milk sugar) so with lactose-free milk it just may not set. You could add some pectin if you want it stiffer ~ Anja

  3. Hi Anja, I’d really like to try this homemade yogurt recipe. I have a question though. I love a thick Greek yogurt. Another recipe I looked at said after letting it sit in a warm place to strain the yogurt in cheesecloth over a glass bowl until the desired thickness. This will also produce whey that can be used for other purposes. In the recipe instructions, you said to let it ferment until it reaches the desired sourness and thickness. Can you explain a little more for me. Is it not necessary to strain at all?

    1. If you just let the yogurt sit longer it will sour more. If you want really thick, Greek-style yogurt, you definitely want to strain it ~ Anja

  4. I put a cup of store bought yogurt into a gallon minus one cup of raw milk, heat on a stove to 110 F, put into tightly lidded quart jars, and put into a medium size ice chest that is filled with equally warm hot tap water, put the lid on the chest, and sit it in a warm area such as the garage (in the summer), and let sit for 24 hours. It turn out like a thick, fermented milk, but not as thick as store bought yogurt, but it still tastes really good!

    1. Sounds great! For a gallon of milk, you could have used up to a cup of yogurt as a starter but I am glad you got good results! Thank you so much for sharing ~ Anja

  5. Pingback: How To Add Fermented Foods To Every Meal - Our Gabled Home
  6. Pingback: Long-fermented apple sauerkraut - Our Gabled Home
  7. Pingback: Ilve Farmhouse Stove Review - Our Gabled Home
  8. Pingback: Sourdough Life-changing bread - Our Gabled Home
  9. Yay!! I love homemade yogurt! I always put mine in the oven with just the light on while it cultures.
    But I love that you pour it into smaller jars prior to letting it culture. I’ve always just let mine culture still in the pot. I guess I usually make Greek yogurt so I have to strain it after it cultures. But I think on my next batch I’ll try just doing regular yogurt and do it your way in the smaller jars. Looks fun. ☺️❤️

    1. I never thought of culturing the yogurt right in the pot … However, since most of the time I don’t strain my yogurt, it’s nice to have it in pretty jars that I can then put straight into the refrigerator. I am so glad you enjoyed this post!

  10. 5 stars
    Love how easy this is! I need to make my own yogurt. Hate all the plastic. Thanks for sharing all the tips and tricks.

  11. Pingback: How we created our Urban Homestead - Our Gabled Home
  12. Pingback: How to make German Quark - Our Gabled Home
  13. Pingback: How to make Cultured Buttermilk - 2 Methods - Our Gabled Home
  14. Pingback: Easy homemade vanilla extract & vanilla sugar - Our Gabled Home
  15. Pingback: Best Homestead Kitchen Tools - Our Gabled Home
  16. Pingback: Slowing down your Kefir - Our Gabled Home
  17. Pingback: Roasting Nuts in a Cast Iron Skillet - Our Gabled Home

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating